Full Disclosure         PMC 30         Client Contract        Core Beliefs        Brochure (Form ADV Part II)

 

Wednesday, June 23, 2010

A Note about the Cumulative Volume Index (CVI)

The Cumulative Volume Index is one of my favorite market strength indicators. This momentum indicator works by subtracting all of the volume of the declining equities from all of the equities that are gaining. The resulting positive or negative number is then added to the previous results. This indicator is very useful in determining how much strength a bullish or bearish move has behind it.

In addition, if there is a divergence in the direction of the CVI in contrast to the S&P, it often serves as a warning sign that there will be a direction change in the market. If the CVI begins to trend down while the averages are moving upwards, it is a bearish sign. If it begins to trend up while the averages are moving downwards, it is a bullish sign.

I'd like to show how useful the CVI can be by giving three real examples of it predicting a change in market direction.















This first chart shows a weekly chart of the SPY ETF (basically the S&P 500) in yellow and the CVI in red and green. The time period that is important here is June 2007 to October 2007.  You can see that the CVI made a high in June 2007 and then failed to meet that high again in October. In contrast, the S&P 500 made a new high in October. The divergence here was a strong indicator that something was wrong with the S&P's last rally. After that high, the S&P fairly rapidly fell from 1576.09 to 666.79. 
















This is a daily chart of the CVI versus the SPY in April 2010. If you remember, we had a pretty nasty 15% correction in April. Once again, the CVI was warning people that were looking for the signal. On April 26th the S&P hit a new recent high of 1219.80. However, the CVI failed to make a new high. What followed was a market correction down to about 1040; completing a 100% retracement of the previous market uptrend.  Don't think however that all signals from the CVI will warn you of that big of a drop. When the divergence happens it can be for market adjustments of all sizes and it can also give you bullish signals.















Here is a daily chart for the relevant period from June 3rd to June 10th, 2010. Here the CVI made a new relative high on June 10th in comparison to June 3rd. In contrast, the S&P was lower on June 10th than it was on June 3rd. This was a bullish divergence signal. After this indicator made the signal the market moved from 1087.85 to 1131.23 (about a 4% upward move).

I hope these examples give you a good idea of how to spot divergence between the S&P 500 and the CVI. The signals don't always work, but they work often enough that if you combine them with some other indicators or fundamental data, you can have a leg up on the market. 

Please remember to always do your own research before investing. If you would prefer for an investment advisor to handle your investments decisions please feel free to contact us as panopticmc@gmail.com.

Gamer Trader: Rating the Stocks Post-E3

Asif and I just had a new article published on Industry Gamers. In the article we give our opinions on the publicly traded companies that were present at the show. You can check it out at www.industrygamers.com.

Sunday, May 9, 2010

Fibonacci Numbers and Moving Averages during the Market Madness

Despite Thursday's record breaking market "anomaly" nearly giving Asif and I coronaries, I thought it created an opportune time to introduce a technical analysis technique that played an important role in the selloff. I'll also use three S&P 500  Charts to go over some of the more interesting moving average relationships with the S&P's recent price movements that occurred around the flash crash.

After an 8% market correction that ended in early February, the S&P started on an impressive rally that ended on April 26th. During that period, the S&P advanced approximately 14.5%. On February 25th, the S&P began using the 20-day moving average as support. I have indicated where the S&P used the 20-day as support with green arrows on the chart below. The S&P finally dropped below its 20-day moving average on On 4/27. This is considered by to be a bearish indicator. On 5/4, the 10-day moving average fell below the 20-day moving average. Many traders will switch from going long to short when they see that type of crossover. However, remember that moving averages are lagging indicators and can be prone to whipsaws (multiple consecutive crossovers resulting in false signals). If you look at 2/22, you will see that there was a bullish crossover of the 10-day over the 20-day. That was thirteen days after the rally had already begun.



 Once it becomes evident that a stock may be in for a correction, people begin to wonder how far it is will drop. In order to arrive at some estimates, you need to look for likely support levels. As stated in a previous article, common moving averages such as the 50, 100, and 200-day moving averages are likely targets. On 5/4 (the light blue arrow), the market clearly bounced off the 50-day moving average. The subsequent day it opened below the 50-day. Other common price levels for a stock to find support are areas of demand. Where there was previous resistance that has been broke, the general rule of thumb is this price now serves as support. 1150 in this case, because of the strong resistance at that level in mid January. Instead of the S&P falling to any of those areas of support, the market closed at a Fibonacci retracement level.

In technical analysis, common retracements of a stock occur at 38.2%, 50%, 61.8%, and 100%. These percentages are all Fibonacci numbers. Why would a stock retrace to these levels? Some people argue it's another case of Fibonacci numbers occurring in nature. Personally, I think it's another case of a self-fulfilling prophecy, but I don't think it is worth arguing over why it works just as long as it actually does work. In order to determine the Fibonacci retracement levels, I took the lowest and highest prices achieved from the rally bottom on February 5th to the rally top on April 26th. The charting software then automatically determines where the Fibonacci levels are located. If you look at the chart above, you can see that on 5/6 the S&P closed at exactly a 50% retracement of its previous rally.* Why is predicting that information useful? Well, if you were short the market that day, you would have an idea of where to cover your short. Or, if you were long, you would have some idea of how much more pain to expect. Since this level serves as some support, the market may rally off of it. Or, it may just serve as a breathing point before the market continues lower (likely to another major level of support.)

*At the time I captured the picture of the chart, there had not yet been a cancellation of a large number of trades that had occurred on 5/6/2010. Once those trades were invalidated, the S&P's official closing price was changed to 1128.15. Given that before these changes were made, the closing price of the S&P was at the 50% retracement level, I believe that the data is still valid.

Support levels do not always work, but they work often enough that they are extremely useful. PMC often tries to buy stocks at or near major support levels. It provides a little insurance that the stock will not go significantly lower. Ideally, you can purchase a stock with multiple support levels directly under where you are purchasing it. Think of them as potential safety nets to break the stock’s fall. It is all too common that if a stock breaks one support level it will drop until it reaches the next one. There are real reasons for why this happens. People have stop loss orders right below support levels that will sell their stock automatically if that level is breached. Traders will get short a stock that has broken a support level and will not cover their short until they reach the next support level. If you know what price levels of a stock or index where the demand is likely to increase, then you can gain a predictive edge against people that completely ignore this information.

 If I haven’t yet convinced you that Fibonacci's and moving averages can affect the intraday fluctuations and closing prices of stocks, let's look at what happened to the S&P on Friday, 5/7. In this first chart you can see that the S&P had its intraday low occur just below the 200-day moving average, here pointed out with a green arrow.


Now, look at where the S&P closed for the day. Though it looks like it closed slightly below 61.8%, on smaller time scale charts, like a 5-minute chart, or hourly chart, you can see that the market closed only very narrowly above 61.8%; reaffirming 61.8% retracement as a support level.

The previous two charts were both daily charts, but I want to demonstrate how moving averages also work on other time frames. Below is a weekly chart of the S&P 500. Thursday was one of the craziest days the stock market has ever experienced. Many members of the media were asking what caused the market to turn around so suddenly. Well, the chart below shows you exactly why that happened. Take a look at the green arrow. The market bottomed at the 50-week moving average. Once this occurred, people, and more importantly, automated trading algorithms switched from being short to being long.  Even in times of market madness, it can follow predictable patterns. Interesting stuff, eh? 














I hope you can see from these examples how powerful moving averages and Fibonacci levels are over market fluctuations. As previously stated, they do not always work. Even when they do work it is often difficult to know exactly which levels are the ones to watch for. Having a long history of following a stock and its price movements can increase the accuracy of your predictions.

If you like the information provided in the article but would prefer for an investment advisory to handle your investment decisions, please feel free to contact us at panopticmc@gmail.com.

Monday, May 3, 2010

PMC Spotlight - Nintendo Inc.

PMC recently had an article analyzing Nintendo Inc. (NTDOY) published on Industry Gamers. Follow this link to read it. We will post the article on our website in a week or so.

Thursday, April 1, 2010

Low Risk High Reward Investments

Mohnish Pabrai, hedge fund manager of Pabrai Investment Funds, is quoted as saying, "Investing is painfully easy for me." While Asif and I don't always feel that way, sometimes opportunities do seem so obvious that we question the market's sanity. As an example, Oil hitting around $35 per barrel in February 2009 last year was one of those moments. It's currently trading at about $85 per barrel.

When these high probability opportunities arise, it's best not to let them go to waste. We at PMC recently stumbled upon one of those opportunities. This is the story of a stock we purchased for some of our clients last Friday. Why only some? Because, we felt some of our clients already had enough exposure to the sector that the investment opportunity was in, and there is still a big difference between a high probability investment and a sure bet. With the market there is no such thing as a sure bet.

The company I will be discussing is Noble Corp symbol NE. Noble Corporation provides offshore contract drilling services for the oil and gas industry worldwide. -Source Yahoo Finance. Noble is a part of the PMC30 and thus we are always keeping a close eye on it among many others. During the trading day I am often thinking in the micro scale of time while after it closes it is easier to consider the macro. Every day after the market closes, I make sure to look and reflect on what's been happening. In the evenings, Asif and I discuss the market that day and what we think is likely to occur in the future. It was last Thursday when I brought up Noble. After talking it over, we decided that we'd consider buying it in the morning.

Here I will attempt to give the overall analysis we used in deciding to purchase the stock. There are a multitude of reasons that all converged towards the decision.

Firstly, we liked the industry. The world needs oil. It would be great if the world had plentiful cheap viable alternatives, but frankly it doesn't. And even if it did, it would take a great deal of time to get the world off oil. Humanity is currently trending towards more consumption not less. Meanwhile, it is a fact that oil supplies are diminishing. Also, Noble deals with offshore drilling and President Obama had already indicated that he was open to more offshore drilling in his State of the Union Address.

Beyond that we looked at the fundamentals of the stock. We consider ourselves value investors. That means we want to buy stocks when we consider them on sale. Noble is inexpensive. Why? Well to keep it short, Noble trades at a less than an 8 forward p/e ratio. It has less than a .6 PEG ratio, and it's price to book ratio is below 1.6. We've explained those ratios in previous articles if you are wondering what they mean. It does have debt, but it also has a lot of cash. Its debt isn't really big enough to consider it a deal breaker. Noble also pays a small dividend which is always a nice thing.

After looking at the fundamentals, we consider the technicals of a stock. Noble had closed on a support level and was only slightly above the convergence of multiple supports. The stock had been fluctuating between a channel range since October 8th, 2009. The stock was nearing two major moving averages. Both the 200-day and 500-day moving averages were less than a dollar below where the stock currently sat. The stock hadn't been below the 200-day moving average since July 8th, 2009. In addition, the lowest the price had closed since October 8th was right about the same level where the 200-day and 500-day now sat. When multiple types of support converge you can assume that strengthens the support. It would take something major for the stock price to break through something like that. I've previously explained moving averages in another article if you need to brush up. Thirdly, the stock was riding along the bottom Bollinger Band. A Bollinger Band is based on the 20-day moving average. What it does is it puts one band 2 standard deviations below the 20-day moving average and one band 2 standard deviations above it. In theory, the stock movements should remain within the bands ~95% of the time. Traders often use these upper and lower bands to look for an entry or exit point in a stock. The Bollinger bands can act like support and resistance. That is, traders buy the stock when it is on the bottom band and sell it once it reaches the top band.















Click on the pictures to enlarge.

Other technical indicators also looked good. The RSI, or Relative Strength Index was nearing oversold. RSI is a momentum indicator that compares the size of recent gains to recent losses in an attempt to determine whether a stock is overbought or oversold. The Stochastics also indicated that the stock was oversold. The Stochastic Oscillator is a momentum indicator that compares a stocks closing price to its price range over a 14-day period. Neither of these indicators is perfect, but when both are showing the same thing, it raises the accuracy of their readings.















Lastly, the volume of trading in the stock had been decreasing over the last 3 days. Since the stock had fallen over those days but the volume kept going down, it indicated to us that the selling pressure was lessening.















On Friday morning, March 26th, we watched the stock closely. We ended up purchasing the stock near its daily low and it closed up with a gain for the day. Based on our analysis on Thursday, we thought that there was likely around a downside of 2% and an upside of around 13% based on Thursday's closing price. When we purchased the stock on Friday it ended up being even better odds. That is what you would call a compelling risk reward scenario.

What would we have done if the stock would have broken below where we thought it could bottom out? A lot of traders would see that as an indication to sell the stock. These traders generally do not care about the fundamentals of a stock and are trading solely on technical analysis. Since we primarily view stocks through their fundamental value, we would generally have seen it as a buying opportunity. If we were willing to buy the stock at a higher price, why would that change if it got even cheaper? The stock is currently up ~7% from where we bought it. Not bad for a week's return. Meanwhile, the S&P 500 returned slightly less than 1% during the same period of time.

This was one of those rare opportunities where everything seemed to line up for us. It's not every day that something like this occurs. I write about it in the hopes that if you see an opportunity like this, you will know to take advantage of it. Warren Buffet said, "There are no called strikes in the ballgame of investing. You do not lose a single penny by passing on any given investment. Even if someone else hits a home run with it, doesn’t mean that you are missing out. That said, you will have to swing the bat if you ever want to get anywhere. Just make sure it is a good pitch." Here we had a good pitch and we made sure to swing. Given that you only have a certain amount of money to invest, why waste it investing on bad pitches? Wait for the opportunities to come to you. Obviously, this requires the diligence to take the time to seek them out. If you don't think you are capable or don't have the time or inclination to hunt out good pitches then consider finding someone whom you trust will do it for you.

Update: We exited our clients' positions in Noble on 4/26/2010 at $43.62 and $43.63.


If you would like more information about our advisory services please contact us at panopticmc@gmail.com.

Monday, March 8, 2010

PMC 30 Spotlight - Apple Inc.

This is the second post in our series of the PMC 30 Spotlight, where we provide an in depth look at an individual stock and explain how it fits into our investment thesis. The PMC 30 can be seen on the right of the blog. Inclusion in the PMC 30 does not mean that we would buy the stocks at their current valuations.

Apple Inc., together with subsidiaries, designs, manufactures, and markets personal computers, mobile communication devices, and portable digital music and video players, as well as sells various related software, services, peripherals, and networking solutions. The company sells its products worldwide through its online stores, retail stores, direct sales force, third-party wholesalers, resellers, and value-added resellers. In addition, it sells various third-party Macintosh, iPhone, and iPod compatible products, including application software, printers, storage devices, speakers, headphones, and various other accessories and peripherals through its online and retail stores, and digital content and applications through the iTunes Store. The company sells its products to consumer, small and mid-sized business, education, enterprise, government, and creative customers. As of September 26, 2009, it had 273 retail stores, including 217 stores in the United States and 56 stores internationally. The company, formerly known as Apple Computer, Inc., was founded in 1976 and is headquartered in Cupertino, California.

During the quarter Apple elected retrospective adoption of the Financial Accounting Standards Board’s amended accounting standards* related to certain revenue recognition. Adoption of the new accounting standards significantly changes how the Company accounts for certain items, particularly sales of iPhone® and Apple TV®. “If you annualize our quarterly revenue, it’s surprising that Apple is now a $50+ billion company,” said Steve Jobs, Apple’s CEO. “The new products we are planning to release this year are very strong, starting this week with a major new product that we’re really excited about.” “We are very pleased to have generated $5.8 billion in cash during the quarter,” said Peter Oppenheimer, Apple’s CFO.

We at Panoptic Management Consultants, Inc. are huge believers in the technology sector. The fundamentals of tech companies are some of the strongest across all of the S&P 500 sectors. In the case of Apple, Inc., they have almost $40 billion in cash and short-term equivalents, and no long term debt. With this amount of cash, they could literally buy Morgan Stanley! Instead, Apple decides to focus all their efforts on innovation and incremental updates of their already existing products.

They have their hands in many of the fastest growing sub-sectors of technology. iPhone has revolutionized the smartphone market, iPod continues to dominate mp3 players, and the Mac computer line continues its comeback story. Macintosh computers have not broken 8% of the US PC market share in over a decade. This in my opinion is the real growth story going on at Apple. Macs are no longer shunned by enterprise users, and the ability to use Windows via BootCamp or Parellels allows PC users to easily transition to the Mac ecosystem. Apple has a virtuous "halo effect" going for them as well. A customer will buy an iPhone, an iMac a year later, etc. Their newest creation, the iPad, launches April 3, 2010. Its aggressive pricing will make it Apple's entrant into the ultramobile computing space.

I was lucky enough to attend the Apple, Inc. Shareholders Meeting on February, 25, 2010. There were a few interesting moments during the shareholder proposed votes on sustainability. At the first opportunity for audience participation just several minutes into the proceeding, a longtime and well-known Apple shareholder--some would say gadfly--who introduced himself as Shelton Ehrlich, stood at the microphone and urged against Al Gore's re-election to the board. Gore "has become a laughingstock. The glaciers have not melted," Ehrlich said, referring to Gore's views on global warming. "If his advice he gives to Apple is as faulty as his views on the environment then he doesn't need to be re-elected." - source CNET What CNET doesn't mention is that the glacier comment drew large amounts of laughter.

After the shareholder votes were cast, there was a question and answer session. CEO Steve Jobs, COO Tim Cook, and CFO Peter Oppenheimer came to the stage. I immediately got in line. I proceeded to hear questions from other shareholders mainly about what to do with the $40 billion in cash on the balance sheet. Dividends, buybacks, and even buying Tesla Motors were suggested. Mr. Jobs had a better idea, TOGA PARTY!

After 6 other shareholders, I got to talk to Mr. Jobs. I told him I had two questions on video gaming:

Why does Apple not have a 1st party developer studio for video games? (Microsoft, Sony and Nintendo all do)

I had an interesting back and forth with Mr. Jobs about this topic. He responded that the thousands of games made by 3rd party developers on the App Store were great, and he didn't see any reason for Apple to compete. I mentioned that "I hear Apple is good at making innovative products, and maybe they could bring something to gaming that other developers hadn't thought of." This even got a laugh from Mr. Jobs.

Would Apple be open to a strategic alliance to bring iTunes content to a video game system?

Netflix has been assaulting Apple on all three video game consoles on the downloadable video front. I broke down the market analysis: Microsoft has the Zune Marketplace, Sony has a load of content. but Nintendo is sitting there not doing much about selling media. I asked if a strategic alliance with Nintendo is something worth doing. He responded that "strategic alliances are tricky, but if they are profitable they are always worth doing."

It was truly a great honor to speak with the 3 top executives at Apple, Inc.

At the time of this post, Apple, Inc. is trading very near its all-time high. It is on the verge of surpassing Walmart for the 4th largest market capitalization in the S&P 500, and has Microsoft in their sights! Not bad for a small company started in a garage in Northern California.

Full Disclosure:

Our CEO, Asif A. Khan, CPA (or his family members) is:

Long Apple, Inc. Common Stock.
Short Apple, Inc. Put Options

Long Nintendo Common Stock
Long Microsoft Common Stock
Long Walmart Common Stock

Long Morgan Stanley Common Stock
Long Morgan Stanley Call Options
Short Morgan Stanley Put Options

Sunday, March 7, 2010

A Supplemental Note on MACD

This note is a supplement to the one below it. I felt it may be useful to show how MACD can be an effective tool on more than just a daily chart of a stock. MACD can be used on any time scale chart and works with indexes in addition to individual stocks. Below is a monthly chart of the S&P 500. The chart covers the period from late 1996 until the present. During that period, the S&P has crashed twice. One was the .com bubble burst that lasted from 2000 until 2003 and the other was the mortgage crisis crash that took place mostly during 2008.
















Remember, usually the MACD histogram bar chart and the stock price chart move in the same direction. That is, if the stock price is going up the MACD histogram is going up and vice-versa. If they are moving in opposite directions, this is a signal that the a directional change may occur in the stock so that it will again be moving in the same direction as the MACD histogram. In those situations, the MACD histogram is a leading indicator. It gives you an idea of what the price of the stock or the index may do in the future.

Sadly, the MACD histogram did not call the bottom of the 2008 market crash. There was no divergence in the MACD histogram and the S&P price to give a signal. The MACD line crossing the signal line did serve as a useful indicator, but it was a lagging indicator. There was already a substantial recovery occurring in the S&P before MACD gave any signal of it. However, MACD divergence did make an accurate and timely prediction of the market top in 2000, the turnaround in 2003, and the market top in 2007. I'm going to discuss the 2003 turnaround and the market top in 2007 because they are the easiest to see.

The first market top occurred in 2000. From that point you can see that the S&P fell from about 1550 to roughly 765 (a downtrend) between the years 2000 and 2003. During that period, the MACD histogram had a pretty deliberate trend moving from the negative to the positive (an uptrend). In early 2003, the MACD line crossed over the gray signal line and the histogram turned positive. From that point, the market continued its trend upward until late 2007. However, the MACD histogram had been trending down towards the negative and finally went negative with the MACD line crossing below the gray signal line in late 2007.

In both situations, people paying close attention to the MACD on the monthly S&P 500 chart would have had a pretty good chance of catching both the bottoms and the tops of the market. Technical investors like to see confirmation of a signal. In the case of the 2007 market top, not only was the MACD signaling that things were going to make a turn for the worse, there was also a "double top". Do you see how the market basically topped out in 2007 at the same point it did in 2000? This is a very common chart pattern that technicians look for, but I'll save further discussion on that topic for another time.